Our Super Premium Ice Cream. While our cookie sandwiches are what made us famous, our ice cream is a close second. We knew the only ice cream good enough to fit between our freshly baked cookies was a super premium ice cream made with the highest amount of butterfat, with a creaminess fit for a queen (or king). Dec 03, 2021 · This christmas ice cream cake is so fun and festive! Made with oreo cookies, ice cream sandwiches and a seasonal peppermint ice cream, it’s always a huge hit. Everyone loves it! ... Chocolate sandwich cookies, like oreos, for the crust. I like to use more than the recipe calls for to get a thick crumbly crust. It’s delish.